Riolo Properties
Zillow's Listing Rules and the Private Listings Debate: What Sellers Should Know

Zillow's Listing Rules and the Private Listings Debate: What Sellers Should Know

  • July 1, 2025

How a home comes to market has become one of the most debated questions in real estate this year. Zillow has new rules that keep many privately marketed listings off its site, Compass has sued over them, and the National Association of Realtors has loosened its own rules. If you are thinking about selling, here is what happened and what it means for you.

What happened

  • March 2025: NAR updated its Clear Cooperation policy to give sellers more options, including a "delayed marketing exempt" listing that can be marketed publicly for a period before it is shared with other brokers through the MLS.
  • April 10, 2025: Zillow announced its Listing Access Standards. A listing that is marketed publicly, whether with a sign, an email blast or an Instagram post, must be added to the MLS within one day. Listings that are not will be barred from Zillow for the life of the listing. Office exclusives that are shared only among agents are still allowed.
  • June 23, 2025: Compass sued Zillow in federal court in New York, arguing that the rules are anticompetitive and limit sellers' choices. Zillow says the claims are unfounded and that publicly marketed listings should be available to every buyer on every site.
  • June 30, 2025: Zillow began enforcing its rules.

The two sides of the argument

The case for private listings: sellers can test a price quietly, avoid building up days on market or a public price cut, and keep their privacy. That matters for well-known buildings, for owners who don't want photos of their home online, and for sellers who are not sure about their price.

The case for listing publicly right away: the most buyers see the home at once, which is what produces competition. Zillow argues that homes marketed to everyone sell for more.

Both can be true for different homes. The right answer depends on your home, your timing and how much privacy you want.

Your options as a seller

Ways to bring a home to market

Option

Who sees it

Good for

Private exclusive

Compass agents and their buyers

Testing price, privacy, sensitive timing

Coming soon

The public, before showings start

Building interest before launch

Full public listing

Every buyer, every site

Reaching the widest pool

Compass's three-phase marketing moves through those steps in order, so you can start privately and still reach the whole market when you are ready. Learn more on our private exclusives page.

What we tell sellers

Choose deliberately. Before you list, decide how long you want to test the market privately, what feedback would make you adjust the price, and when you will go fully public. We'll walk you through the trade-offs for your home. Call the Riolo Properties team at 917-905-0099.

Sources: Zillow Group, "Updating Zillow's Listing Access Standards" (April 2025); RISMedia (April 10, 2025); The Real Deal, "Compass sues Zillow" (June 23, 2025); Inman (April and June 2025).

Contact Us

Our team prides itself on our diverse backgrounds, our depth of market knowledge, and our commitment to client satisfaction. Bringing passion to every deal, we enable our clients to be the best-educated decision-makers in the market and we are fulfilled by their successes. With decades of combined real estate experience.