Riolo Properties
Congestion Pricing Begins: What It Means for Manhattan and Brooklyn Homes

Congestion Pricing Begins: What It Means for Manhattan and Brooklyn Homes

  • January 8, 2025

On Sunday, January 5, 2025, New York became the first U.S. city to charge drivers to enter its busiest district. The MTA's Congestion Relief Zone toll is now live, and it is already part of the conversation when clients weigh where to buy, where to rent and whether to keep a car.

How the toll works

  • The zone: Manhattan below 60th Street. The FDR Drive and the West Side Highway are not included.
  • The price: most passenger cars with E-ZPass pay $9 to enter during peak hours (5 a.m. to 9 p.m. on weekdays, 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. on weekends) and $2.25 overnight. You pay once a day, no matter how many times you enter.
  • Credits and discounts: drivers who already paid a toll at certain tunnels get a crossing credit during peak hours, and the MTA offers a low-income discount plan and a disability exemption.
  • Where the money goes: the program is expected to support $15 billion of transit investment, with 80% going to subways and buses and 10% each to Metro-North and the LIRR.

Toll for a passenger car with E-ZPass (MTA)

Peak hours: $9.00

Overnight: $2.25

What it could mean for homes

It is far too early for sales data to show any effect, so be wary of anyone who claims to know. What we can do is lay out the questions our clients are asking.

Living inside the zone. Residents of the zone do not pay to drive around inside it, but they do pay each day they drive back in from outside. For owners in Tribeca, the West Village, Chelsea or the Financial District who drive out of the city every weekend, that is a new line in the budget. For the many downtown owners who don't keep a car, nothing changes, and quieter streets and faster buses would be a plus.

Parking spaces. Buildings with garages below 60th Street will be worth watching. If fewer people drive in, demand for monthly parking may soften; if residents keep cars but drive less, it may not change much.

Brooklyn commuters. Many Brooklyn buyers already commute by subway. For those who drive into Manhattan for work, the toll adds to the case for neighborhoods with fast subway lines, like Brooklyn Heights, Park Slope, Fort Greene and Clinton Hill.

Just north of 60th Street. The Upper East and Upper West Sides sit outside the zone. Some drivers may value that more now.

What we will be watching

  • Whether traffic and bus speeds in the zone change in the first months
  • Any shift in demand for garage spaces and for homes near subway hubs
  • The court challenges and federal review that could still change the program

We track sales and listings across downtown Manhattan and Brownstone Brooklyn every month. See our Downtown Manhattan guide and Brownstone Brooklyn guide, or call the Riolo Properties team at 917-905-0099 to talk about how the toll fits into your plans.

Sources: MTA, "New York Joins World Cities in Launch of First-in-the-Nation Program" (January 2025); MTA Congestion Relief Zone toll information.

Contact Us

Our team prides itself on our diverse backgrounds, our depth of market knowledge, and our commitment to client satisfaction. Bringing passion to every deal, we enable our clients to be the best-educated decision-makers in the market and we are fulfilled by their successes. With decades of combined real estate experience.