Riolo Properties
Lower Manhattan skyline at dusk, with One World Trade Center rising above the waterfront.

The K-Shaped Housing Market: Why Luxury Is Holding Up While Entry-Level Buyers Wait

  • September 15, 2026

Economists have a shorthand for an economy where one group pulls ahead while another stalls: the K shape. One arm of the K points up, the other points down. In 2026 that pattern has shown up clearly in housing, and New York City is one of the places where you can see it most plainly.

What the numbers show

Redfin, which defines a luxury home as one in the top 5% of its metro area, reported that the median U.S. luxury sale price rose 3.6% to $1.39 million in the three months ending April 30, 2026. Over the same period, the median price of all other homes rose 1.4% to $377,734. Pending luxury sales jumped in several markets, including San Francisco, Tampa, West Palm Beach and Miami.

Price growth, three months ending April 30, 2026 (Redfin)

Luxury homes (top 5%): +3.6% to a median of $1.39 million

All other homes: +1.4% to a median of $377,734

In Manhattan, appraiser Jonathan Miller of Miller Samuel reported a record share of all-cash buyers in 2025. Cash buyers are less exposed to mortgage rates, which is exactly why the top of the market has kept moving while many first-time buyers wait.

Why the split is happening

  • Stock market and compensation gains. Higher-income households have seen their savings and portfolios grow, and many can buy with cash or large down payments.
  • Mortgage rates. Rates dipped below 6% in February, then climbed back toward 7% over the summer. Every move up hits buyers who need financing harder than buyers who don't.
  • Home equity. Owners who bought years ago have substantial equity to roll into the next purchase. First-time buyers start from zero.

What it means in Brooklyn and Manhattan

New York has always had a wide spread between its entry-level co-ops and its townhouses and penthouses, but the gap in how those segments behave is wider now than it was a few years ago. In our day-to-day work we see it in a few ways:

  • Well-priced townhouses and larger condos in prime Brownstone Brooklyn and Downtown Manhattan blocks still draw multiple offers, often from buyers who are not financing.
  • Studios and one-bedrooms, especially co-ops that need strict debt-to-income ratios, take longer, and buyers negotiate harder.
  • Sellers trading up are in a strong position if they sell first and buy with the proceeds; sellers trading down benefit from the deeper pool of cash buyers at the top.

What to do with this

If you are buying at the entry level, the slower pace is an opportunity. You can ask for a price reduction, a credit or a longer closing, and you face less competition than buyers at the top. Get fully pre-approved and keep your co-op board package ready so you can move when the right apartment appears.

If you are selling a larger home, price it against the most recent closed sales rather than last year's peak, and plan your launch carefully. The buyer pool is strong but selective.

If you are selling a smaller apartment, presentation and pricing matter more than ever. Staging, great photography and a realistic first price are what get it sold.

Our team tracks these numbers every month for 26 Brooklyn and Manhattan neighborhoods. See the latest on our market reports page, or call the Riolo Properties team at 917-905-0099 to talk through what the market means for your next move.

Sources: Redfin luxury market data as reported by Axios (May 27, 2026); Miller Samuel.

Contact Us

Our team prides itself on our diverse backgrounds, our depth of market knowledge, and our commitment to client satisfaction. Bringing passion to every deal, we enable our clients to be the best-educated decision-makers in the market and we are fulfilled by their successes. With decades of combined real estate experience.